Pin it
These homemade baked crème brûlée donuts mix fluffy yeast-raised pastry with velvety custard filling and a crisp, caramelized sugar coating that captures the essence of the famous French dessert. I whipped these up for my daughter's birthday gathering and they've since become our family's top pick for celebration treats.
I first created these donuts when I wanted something fancy but didn't feel like messing with hot oil. The second my family heard that distinctive snap of breaking through the sugar top, they were instantly sold.
What You'll Need
- Whole milk: Brings creaminess to your pastry filling and dough grab full fat for the tastiest outcome
- Egg yolks: Give your custard filling that smooth texture and sunny color
- Cornstarch: Makes your filling thick without turning it rubbery
- Instant yeast: Works consistently for bakers at any skill level
- Vanilla extract: Stick with real vanilla instead of artificial for genuine taste
- Unsalted butter: Adds softness to your dough and filling
- All purpose flour: Creates the backbone while keeping donuts tender
- Granulated sugar: Needed for sweetness and that iconic crunchy topping
How To Make Them
Pin it
- Cook up the custard filling:
- Warm the milk until it steams without letting it boil to build flavor without ruining it. Slowly add warm milk into your egg mixture, stirring constantly so the eggs don't cook too quickly. Put everything back on the stove and keep whisking until it gets as thick as pudding, taking about 5-10 minutes. Don't rush this step if you want ultra-smooth results.
- Whip up your donut dough:
- Get your yeast going by mixing it with warm milk and a spoonful of sugar until it bubbles, about 5-10 minutes. This means your donuts will puff up nicely. Stir all wet stuff together well before adding flour bit by bit to avoid clumps. Work the dough for at least 5 minutes until it feels smooth - this builds the right texture.
- Let it rise and shape:
- Put your dough in a greased bowl and leave it somewhere warm until it doubles in size, taking 45-60 minutes. This creates flavor and fluffiness. Roll the dough out to 1/2 inch thick for just the right balance. Cut out circles with a 3-inch cutter and save leftover dough to make more donuts.
- Final rise and oven time:
- Let your cut donuts puff up again until they look noticeably bigger, about 30-45 minutes, which makes them extra light. Bake at 375°F for only 10-12 minutes until they just turn golden on top. Keep an eye on them during the last few minutes since they'll dry out if they cook too long.
- Add filling and finish:
- Poke a hole in each cooled donut and squeeze in cold custard until it starts coming back out. For the crunchy top, cook sugar with water and salt until it turns amber. Carefully dip each filled donut into the hot sugar mix using tongs to create that signature crackly surface.
I really love adding Madagascar bourbon vanilla to the custard since it brings flowery hints that make the whole dessert taste extra special. The first time I brought these to a family party, my nephew said they beat the fancy bakery ones we usually splurge on for celebrations.
Fixing Caramel Problems
Making the sugar topping might seem tricky but watch the color for your clue. You want something between honey and amber, not dark brown which tastes bitter. If sugar crystals form while cooking, just put the lid on for a few moments to create steam that melts them away. You can always warm the caramel on low heat if it gets too hard before you finish dipping all your donuts.
Keeping Them Fresh
You can keep unfilled donuts in a sealed container at room temp for up to 2 days. After filling, they should go in the fridge and are best eaten within 24 hours. Try to add the crunchy sugar top right before serving to keep that snap. For longer keeping, freeze plain donuts, then thaw them completely before adding filling.
Try Different Flavors
Mix some orange or lemon zest into your custard for a fruity kick. When heating the milk, try adding lavender, chai spices, or coffee beans for grown-up flavors. Switch out some vanilla for almond extract to get a marzipan taste. You can also spread a thin layer of jam under the custard for an extra fruity surprise.
Pin it
When you nail the mix of textures and flavors, these crème brûlée donuts will steal the show at any special event. Savor that satisfying crack with every bite!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why let the dough rise two times?
Letting the dough rise twice improves flavor and texture. The first rise creates that airy softness, while the second ensures light donuts after shaping. Skipping either rise could lead to dense, heavy results.
- → Can I prep the cream earlier?
Absolutely! You can make the cream up to 3 days ahead. Store it in the fridge with plastic wrap pressed against the surface to stop skin from forming. It’ll save you time and deepen the flavor.
- → Why does my sugar harden unevenly?
This usually happens when crystals form in the caramel mixture. Avoid stirring with a spoon—swirl the pan instead. Use a wet brush to clear the sides of the pan where crystals might stick, or allow steam condensation to handle it. If it hardens the wrong way, just start fresh for that perfect crunch.
- → How can I tell the dough is ready?
The dough needs to double in size. Try the poke test—press a finger lightly into the dough. If it slowly bounces back or leaves a faint dent, you’re good to go. If it springs back quickly, give it more time.
- → How long can these donuts stay good?
The caramel topping doesn’t stay crunchy long, so enjoy them within 24 hours. If you haven’t added the topping yet, store the filled donuts in the fridge for up to 2 days in a sealed container. Add the caramel just before eating for the best texture.
- → Can I freeze these donuts?
You can freeze the baked, unfilled donuts for about 1 month. Let them thaw fully, then add the filling and caramel. Once they’re topped or filled, freezing isn’t ideal since the textures won’t hold up.