Pin it
Transform your home cooking with this foolproof Air Fryer Steak recipe that delivers restaurant-quality results in just 17 minutes. The rapid air circulation creates a perfect golden crust while keeping the interior tender and juicy - a technique that rivals traditional grilling methods.
After extensive testing, this streamlined cooking method consistently produces exceptional steaks with remarkable ease.
Key Ingredients
- NY Strip Steak: Select well-marbled cuts approximately 1-inch thick for optimal results
- Canola Oil: Choose this high smoke point oil for better searing
- Fresh Garlic: Select firm, unblemished cloves for the compound butter
- Butter: Unsalted variety allows better seasoning control
- Fresh Parsley: Adds color and fresh flavor to the finished dish
Cooking Instructions
- Initial Preparation:
- Let steaks reach room temperature for 15 minutes. Thoroughly dry with paper towels. Trim excess fat, leaving a thin layer. Coat with canola oil and season generously. Rest while the air fryer preheats.
- Cooking Process:
- Heat air fryer to 400°F. Position steaks in basket with adequate spacing. Cook according to desired doneness, maintaining a closed basket throughout cooking.
Proper steak placement in the air fryer basket significantly impacts results. Center positioning ensures optimal air circulation and even cooking. This method consistently produces impressive results that have made it a regular part of our dinner rotation.
Pin it
Cooking Times for Different Doneness
Standard cooking times for 1-inch steaks: 10 minutes yields medium-rare with red center, 12 minutes for medium with pink center, 14 minutes achieves medium-well. Adjust timing proportionally for different thicknesses.
Compound Butter Enhancement
The finishing garlic butter transforms this dish into something extraordinary. As it melts over the resting steak, it creates a luxurious sauce. Prepare extra compound butter and freeze for future use.
Menu Planning
Coordinate side dishes efficiently by preparing air fryer potatoes during the steak's resting period and assembling a fresh salad while the steak comes to room temperature.
This technique brings steakhouse quality to home cooking. The precision of air frying combined with rich compound butter creates consistently excellent results that rival professional preparations.
Pin it
While maintaining the core technique, adapt the seasonings and accompaniments to personal preference. The reliability of this method proves that precision often surpasses complexity.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why should steak be room temperature before cooking?
- Letting steak sit out for 10-15 minutes before cooking helps it heat evenly from edge to center, meaning no overcooked outsides or undercooked insides.
- → How can I check my steak’s doneness?
- For medium-rare, aim for around 10 minutes. Medium? Go for 12. Medium-well? About 14 minutes does it. Remember, the steak will finish cooking a little after resting.
- → Is it okay to use a different steak cut?
- Absolutely! Cuts like ribeye or sirloin work well—just make sure they’re about an inch thick so the cook time stays consistent. Thinner or thicker cuts will need adjustments.
- → Do I need to turn the steak mid-cook?
- Nope! The circulating heat in the air fryer does all the work, giving you evenly cooked steak without flipping.
- → How long should I rest my steak after cooking?
- Give it a quick wait—about 5 to 10 minutes—to lock in those flavorful juices before slicing.
- → Can I prep the garlic butter in advance?
- Sure thing! Make it up to three days ahead and pop it in the fridge. Before using, let it soften at room temperature for easy spreading.