Simple French Toast Muffins

These handheld French toast cups turn a traditional morning favorite into something you can grab on the go. They pack all the warm, cozy flavor of cinnamon-dusted French toast but in a neat muffin shape that's perfect when you're rushing out the door while still giving you that homey taste everyone loves.

I came up with these cups during a hectic family get-together when I needed to feed everyone breakfast but didn't want to miss out on family time by flipping endless slices of French toast. They've become such a hit that relatives now expect them at every gathering, and I'm known as the breakfast guru in our family circle.

What You'll Need

• Eggs: They give the cups their form and richness as they bake from liquid into that custardy texture
• Milk: Brings the right amount of moisture grab the whole milk for extra creaminess
• Vanilla extract: Gives that wonderful smell we all connect with French toast go for real vanilla for best results
• Cinnamon: Delivers that cozy warmth and classic taste try Ceylon type for something special
• Sugar: Adds just the right sweetness swap in brown sugar if you want a deeper flavor
• Bread cubes: They're what it's all about slightly dried-out bread actually works better here
• Melted butter: Makes the tops turn beautifully golden and tastes amazing
• Maple syrup: Finishes everything off perfectly real maple beats artificial syrup any day

How To Make Them

Get things ready:

Set your oven to 350°F before you start anything else. Coat your muffin tin completely, getting into all the corners. Cooking spray with flour works great, but a good coating of butter does the trick too if you cover every spot.

Mix the wet stuff:

In a big bowl, beat those eggs until they're light and bubbly. Pour in milk, vanilla, cinnamon, and sugar, then keep whisking until everything blends together smoothly with no sugar bits left. The mix should look a bit thick, kind of like cream.

Let the bread drink it up:

Dump your bread cubes into the egg mixture and fold everything together gently. Let it all sit for about 3-5 minutes, pushing down now and then so all the bread gets soaked through. Don't rush this part it's key to getting that real French toast feel.

Load up the muffin tin:

Scoop the soaked bread into your greased muffin cups. Fill each one about three-quarters full, making sure to get liquid in each cup too. Press each one down lightly so the bread packs in without getting smashed, leaving room for the custard to puff up while baking.

Add that buttery topping:

Spoon about a teaspoon of your melted butter over each filled cup. This butter will make the tops turn crispy and golden, creating an awesome contrast with the soft middle. This little touch takes these from good to amazing.

Bake them up:

Put your tin on the middle rack of your hot oven. Let them bake for 20-25 minutes, turning the pan halfway for even browning. You'll know they're done when they've puffed up big, turned golden on top, and a toothpick comes out mostly clean with just a few moist bits.

Let them settle and pop them out:

Let the muffins cool in the tin for 5 minutes. This helps them firm up. Run a knife around each one to loosen the edges, then carefully take them out. If any stick, wait another minute before trying again.

Dig in:

Put your warm muffins on a plate. Sprinkle with cinnamon sugar if you want or pour some maple syrup over them. Add fresh berries or whipped cream for something extra fancy. They taste best while still warm when you can really enjoy that contrast between the slightly crunchy outside and soft inside.

Pin it

The cinnamon really makes this dish special for my family. I found this out completely by chance when I accidentally put in twice as much as I meant to. That mistake turned out so amazing with such a warm, spicy smell that my family now insists I make them this way every time. Now just smelling cinnamon brings back memories of our Sunday family breakfasts, even when we're far apart.

How To Save For Later

These cups work great as a prepare-ahead breakfast choice. Once they've cooled down completely, put them in a sealed container in the fridge where they'll stay good for about 4 days. If you want to keep them longer, wrap each one in plastic and stick them in a freezer bag they'll last up to 3 months that way. To warm up refrigerated cups, pop them in the microwave for 20-30 seconds or heat them in a 300°F oven for about 10 minutes. If they're frozen, add another minute in the microwave or 5 more minutes in the oven. They'll taste almost like fresh-baked when warmed up right.

Mix It Up With These Flavors

What's great about these French toast cups is how easy they are to change up. Try making a cinnamon raisin version by tossing in 1/2 cup of soaked raisins. For something sweeter, mix in 1/3 cup mini chocolate chips before baking. My family really loves the apple cinnamon version just mix in 1/2 cup of small apple pieces that you've cooked in a bit of butter and cinnamon. Want something different? Add 1/3 cup of toasted coconut and use coconut milk instead of regular milk. Each twist keeps that cozy French toast feeling but brings something new to the table.

What To Serve With Them

These cups taste great on their own, but the right sides can make breakfast even better. Some fresh berries give a nice tangy contrast to the sweet cups. A few slices of crispy bacon create that perfect sweet-salty combo that makes breakfast so satisfying. For a fancy brunch, serve them with a light fruit salad drizzled with honey and mint. If you've got guests over, set up a topping bar with different fruit sauces, nut butters, whipped cream, and various syrups so everyone can fix their cups just how they like them.

Pin it

Enjoy these cups while they're still warm and smelling amazing they'll start your morning off right or make a wonderful snack anytime!

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I prep toast muffins ahead of time?

Totally! Mix the bread and eggs the evening before and keep it covered and chilled in the fridge. In the morning, lightly mix it up again, pop it into muffin tins, and bake. It’s great for saving time on busy days or hosting brunches.

→ Which bread works best for toast muffins?

Use bread that’s a little older—it soaks up flavor but won’t go mushy. Sweet breads like brioche or challah are rich options, but whole wheat adds fiber and a gentle nuttiness. Avoid soft, freshly baked loaves since they might fall apart.

→ Can I store these muffins in the freezer?

Absolutely! After cooling them down, pop them on a sheet to freeze firm, then store in airtight containers for up to 3 months. You can reheat them in the microwave for about 40 seconds or in a warm oven until they’re ready.

→ How can I customize French toast muffins?

There are loads of options! Throw in fruits like blueberries, stir in some chocolate chips, or toss in nuts for crunch. For different flavors, try adding citrus zest to the egg mix. Switch up the toppings too—powdered sugar, fruit syrups, or even cream are all fun choices.

→ Why are my muffins wet in the middle?

A gooey center might mean you didn’t bake them long enough or there’s too much liquid in your mix. Bake until the tops are golden and bounce back slightly. Using soft, fresh bread? Cut back a little on the milk. Let them rest in the muffin tin for about 10 minutes to firm up before removing.

→ How do I make these muffins dairy-free?

Easy swap! Use almond, oat, or another plant-based milk instead of regular milk. For butter, try coconut oil or a dairy-free alternative. It tweaks the taste slightly, but they’ll still be delicious!