Pin it
These crunchy Amish onion patties turn basic stuff into a tasty treat that's both cozy and hard to resist. The golden outside breaks open to a soft, onion-packed middle that pops with flavor every time you take a bite.
I found this dish during a trip to Pennsylvania Dutch area a while back, and now it's my favorite thing to make when friends come over. Don't let the simple ingredients fool you – these fritters pack amazing taste.
Ingredients
- Sweet onions: They bring natural sweetness that turns golden when fried
- All purpose flour: Forms the right base for airy but filling fritters
- Sugar: Boosts the onions' sweetness and helps them turn brown
- Baking powder: Gives just enough rise for soft fritters
- Salt and pepper: Rounds out the flavors and makes the onions taste even better
- Milk: Holds everything together with the perfect texture
- Oil for frying: Makes that can't-miss golden crust
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare the dry ingredients:
- Mix the flour, sugar, baking powder, salt, and pepper together in a big bowl until well combined. When everything's evenly mixed, each fritter will taste good all the way through and rise properly.
- Add the onions and milk:
- Carefully fold the finely chopped onions into your dry mix, then add the milk. Mix just enough to get rid of dry spots. Your batter should be thick with chunks and you should see onion pieces throughout. Don't mix too much or your fritters will come out tough.
- Heat the oil:
- Add about 2 inches of oil to a heavy pot or deep pan. Warm it over medium-high heat until it reaches 375°F. A thermometer helps make sure you're frying at the right heat, so your fritters won't be oily or raw inside.
- Fry the fritters:
- Drop spoonfuls of batter carefully into the hot oil, leaving room between them since they'll grow a bit. Cook in small batches so the oil stays hot – crowded pans make soggy fritters.
- Achieve golden perfection:
- Cook each fritter for 2-3 minutes on each side, flipping when the edges look golden. Look for a deep golden color all around, which means they're done right and taste their best.
- Drain and serve:
- Lift the cooked fritters out with a slotted spoon onto paper towels, which soaks up extra oil while keeping them crispy. Eat them right away while hot for the best crunch.
Pin it
Sweet onions really make this dish special. I like using Vidalia or Walla Walla when I can find them, since their sweetness makes these savory fritters almost taste like dessert. My grandma always told me that good onions make good fritters.
Dipping Sauce Options
These fritters go great with lots of different sauces. My top pick is a basic garlic aioli made from mayo, chopped garlic, lemon juice, and a bit of salt. If you want something tangy, try sour cream mixed with fresh herbs like dill or chives. Apple butter is what traditional Amish folks use, and it makes a nice sweet-savory mix. Keep your sauces pretty simple so you can still taste the onion flavor.
Make-Ahead Tips
These taste best fresh and hot, but you can get them partly ready ahead of time when you have guests. You can mix all the dry stuff up to a day before and keep it in a sealed container. You can chop the onions a few hours early and put them in the fridge. When you're ready to cook, just mix everything and fry. If you really need to make them completely ahead, you can warm them up in a 350°F oven for 5-7 minutes, though they won't be as crunchy as fresh ones.
Amish Cooking Tradition
These fritters show what's great about Amish cooking, where basic ingredients become amazing food through careful cooking. People usually served onion fritters as a side dish in late summer and fall when onions were everywhere. The Amish didn't waste anything, so these fritters became a way to use extra onions and make something tasty for the family. The recipe hasn't changed much for many years, which shows how perfect it is in its simplicity.
Pin it
Make sure to eat these onion fritters while they're steaming hot for the best taste!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What kind of onions should I use?
Go for sweet varieties like Vidalia, Walla Walla, or Spanish onions for a naturally sweet taste. But if you want a stronger flavor, yellow onions work too!
- → Can I mix the batter in advance?
You can prep the batter about 30 minutes early, but not too much longer or the onions will release water, affecting the mix. Keep it cool in the fridge and stir gently before cooking.
- → What dips work well with these fritters?
These fritters are yummy with sour cream, ranch dressing, aioli, or spicy sriracha mayo. For a sweet twist, try a dollop of apple butter or some maple syrup for that Amish vibe!
- → How can I check if the oil is hot enough?
If you don’t have a thermometer, toss a little batter into the oil. It should sizzle and float without burning right away. The fritters need 2–3 minutes per side, so adjust the heat if they brown too fast.
- → How do I keep the fritters crisp before serving?
Lay them on paper towels to drain, then pop them on a wire rack in a warm oven (200°F/95°C) until ready to eat. Skip foil as it traps steam and softens the crunch.
- → Can I add extra stuff to the batter?
Sure! Mix in 1/4 cup of corn kernels, a sprinkle of fresh herbs like parsley or dill, 1/4 cup of shredded cheese, or a bit of bacon for an extra punch of flavor without losing the texture.